I spoke on a panel of four HIE representatives.
- David Katz, former Executive Director of the Smart Valley Task Force
- Will Ross, Project Manager, Redwood MedNet
- Laura Landry, Executive Director, Long Beach Network for Health
- Molly Coye, MD, Chair, Board of Directors, CalRHIO
Molly opened with the three important characteristics of CalRHIO.
- It is sustainable
- It is secure
- It will be self-financing over time
- Rapid deployment of HIE across the state
- Providing the state with a plan to enable California to move to the front of the line for drawdown of federal funds
- Offering the State the opportunity to recognize a broad public private partnership, designate an organization, and apply for federal funds
- An additional opportunity to maximize federal stimulus funds based on meaningful use of HIE
- Establish a public private partnership that provides a core technology for HIE
Briefly comparing these remarks to the other HIE presentation to the committee, the following contrasts are apparent.
- Smart Valley presented a detailed and practical analysis of the fiscal disincentives facing the launch and operation of an HIE service. The analysis did not spare state or federal health IT leadership with regard to incubating and enabling viable business models for HIE services. I find it hard to overstate the importance of Smart Valley's experience, which included a thorough and realistic vetting of hard boiled financial projections. In contrast, CalRHIO presented a financial model with massive HIE revenue generation, but I am unaware of any substantial public vetting of the CalRHIO revenue model.
- Redwood MedNet presented a methodical, chronological and incremental narrative showing steady progress through planning stages to the launch of an operating HIE, with practical details for integration of HIE services into the work flow of local clinical practices. In contrast, CalRHIO, an organization still in the HIE planning stage, presented a high level plan to rapidly deploy full HIE services statewide, with no recognition of the nuts and bolts of deployment or of actual integration with clinical practices.
- Long Beach Network for Health explained why they are creating HIE services, how they are building it, how far along they are as one of nine successful NHIE's funded by the federal government. Laura also emphasized shared community trust and a focus on supporting and collaborating with safety net and public health stakeholders, and how the Long Beach core infrastructure is installed and is scalable up to millions of lives. In contrast, CalRHIO asked the state to bypass any of the six HIEs that are already functioning in California by suggesting that the CalRHIO plan, which has never been tested, has the greatest likelihood of quickly deploying across the state.
